Catholic priests in public office
Catholic priests in public office — A number of Catholic priests have served in public office.[1] The Catholic Church discourages and restricts this practice.
In canon law
Roman Catholic canon law discourages and restricts members of the clergy from holding secular civil or political office. Canon 285 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law, which governs the Latin Church, states that priests "are to avoid those things which, although not unbecoming, are nevertheless foreign to the clerical state" and prohibits clergy from assuming "public offices which entail a participation in the exercise of civil power."[2][3] The same canon makes an exception for priests who have the permission of their bishop.[2][3]
Laws by country
The constitutions of Bolivia, Costa Rica, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, and Venezuela prohibit members of the clergy from serving as president.[4] The Constitution of Paraguay prohibits clergy of any religion from becoming candidates for president, vice president, senator, deputy, or departmental governor.[5] The Constitution of Myanmar prohibits "members of religious orders" from serving as president or as members of the Pyithu Hluttaw, the lower house of parliament.[4][6] Article 130 of the Constitution of Mexico prohibits clergy from holding any public office, among other restrictions.[4][7]
Andorra
The Bishop of Urgell is a ruling co-prince of Andorra; the bishop's ex officio role as a monarch has existed since 1278. The bishop additionally sends a personal representative to rule as a viceroy in their stead.
United States
In the early days of the American republic, many states had laws prohibiting clergy from holding public office. Most states repealed these laws, and only Maryland and Tennessee continued to have these laws in the 20th century. In 1974, a federal district court held the Maryland statute unconstitutional, and in 1978, in McDaniel v. Paty, the U.S. Supreme Court held the Tennessee statute unconstitutional. The effect of McDaniel is that no state or federal government may constitutionally prohibit clergy from holding public office.[8]
Examples by country
Austria
Ignaz Seipel, a priest, theologian and academic, served as the Foreign Minister of Austria from 1926 to 1929 and in 1930, and served as Chancellor of Austria from 1922 to 1924 and 1926 to 1929.
Theodor Innitzer, who would become a cardinal and Archbishop of Vienna, served as the Austrian Minister of Social Affairs from 1929 to 1930.
Canada
Three Catholic priests have been elected to the House of Commons of Canada.
Andrew Hogan was the first Catholic priest to serve as a Canadian Member of Parliament. First elected to represent the electoral district of Cape Breton—East Richmond, Nova Scotia, in the 1974 federal election, he was re-elected in 1979 but defeated in 1980. Hogan was a member of the New Democratic Party.
Robert Ogle was elected to the House of Commons in 1979 in the electoral district of Saskatoon East, Saskatchewan. Ogle was re-elected in 1980. He chose not to seek re-election in 1984 as a result of the new ban by the Holy See on clergy in public office. Like Hogan, Ogle was a member of the New Democratic Party.
Raymond Gravel was elected in a 2006 by-election in the electoral district of Repentigny, Quebec. He had received a dispensation from his diocesan bishop to enter politics. Gravel did not seek re-election in the 2008 federal election after Holy See authorities ordered him to choose between politics and the priesthood following controversy over his opposition to anti-abortion Bill C-484 and his support for the Order of Canada nomination of abortion rights activist Henry Morgentaler. Although he chose to leave politics, Gravel maintained that he remained, in accordance with Catholic doctrine, opposed to abortion.[9] Gravel was a member of the nationalist Bloc Québécois.
Czech Republic
Daniel Herman is a laicized Roman Catholic priest who was Minister of Culture, representing the Christian Democratic Union – Czechoslovak People's Party (KDU-ČSL).
Dominican Republic
Fernando Arturo de Meriño, a priest who would later become an archbishop, served as President of the Dominican Republic from 1880 to 1882.
France
Barthélemy Boganda, a priest from Ubangi-Shari (today the Central African Republic), was elected to the French National Assembly in 1946, serving until 1958. He left the priesthood in 1950 and married, and from 1958 to 1959 served as the first Prime Minister of the Central African Republic.
Germany
Beda Weber was a German Benedictine priest who served as a member of the Frankfurt Parliament in 1849.
Ludwig Kaas was a priest of the Weimar Republic. In 1919 he was elected to the Weimar National Assembly and in 1920 was elected to the Reichstag, where he served until 1933.
Libya
For a brief period in 2011 during the Libyan Civil War, the Nicaraguan priest Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann served as the Libyan ambassador to the United Nations.
Nicaragua
In the 1970s and 80s, the President of Nicaragua, Daniel Ortega, appointed three priests to his cabinet: Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann as Minister of Foreign Affairs, Fernando Cardenal as Minister of Education, and his brother, Ernesto Cardenal, as Minister of Culture.
Nigeria
In 2023 Fr. Hyacinth Iormem Alia, a Nigerian Catholic cleric and politician was elected to serve as a Nigerian governor in the state of Benue on 29 May 2023.
Paraguay
In 2005, Fernando Lugo, the Bishop of San Pedro, requested laicization to run for office but it was denied. In 2008, he was elected President of Paraguay, in spite of Article 235 of the Constitution prohibiting any minister of any religion from serving as president. After his election he was laicized. In 2012, he was impeached for unrelated reasons.
Poland
Hugo Kołłątaj was a Polish noble and Catholic priest who in 1786 received the office of the Referendary of Lithuania. He co-authored the Constitution of May 3, 1791 and held a variety of posts before falling out of political favor in 1802 as a result of his radical views.
Stanisław Staszic was a philosopher and political activist who served in the government of Congress Poland.
Slovakia and Czechoslovakia
Andrej Hlinka served in the Parliament of Czechoslovakia from 1920 to 1938 and was leader of the Slovak People's Party from 1913 until his death.
From 1939 to 1945, the priest Jozef Tiso was President of the First Slovak Republic, a satellite state of Nazi Germany. Following World War II, he was convicted and hanged for treason that subsumed also war crimes, and crimes against humanity.
Solomon Islands
Augustine Geve was a Catholic priest who served as a member of the National Parliament from 2001 to 2002 and was Minister of Youth, Women and Sports from 2001 to 2002. He was assassinated on 20 August 2002.
United Kingdom
David Cairns, a laicised Catholic priest, was elected to the House of Commons of the United Kingdom between 2001 and 2011, following the House of Commons (Removal of Clergy Disqualification) Act 2001 which removed the ban on clergymen being elected as an MP.[10] Former Archbishops of Westminster Basil Hume and Cormac Murphy-O'Connor were individually offered life peerages and a seat in the House of Lords but both declined the offer.[11][12]
United States
Possibly the earliest known instance of a Catholic priest serving in public office in the United States was Gabriel Richard. Born in France, he founded the University of Michigan and served as a delegate from Michigan Territory from 1823 to 1825.
Two priests, Robert Drinan and Robert John Cornell, have served in the United States Congress. In 1980, when Pope John Paul II decreed that priests not serve in elected office,[13] Representative Drinan withdrew from his re-election campaign, and Cornell withdrew from his bid to re-gain the seat he had lost in the 1978 Congressional election. In 1983, the prohibition on serving in governmental office was codified as section 3 of canon 285 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law.
List of priests who have held public office
This list includes priests who held public office, the country in which they held office, and the office(s) they held.
| Name | Country | Office(s) | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moses Adasu | Nigeria | Governor of Benue State (1992–1993) | [14] |
| Paul-Siméon Ahouanan Djro | Ivory Coast | President of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (2015–2017) | [3] |
| Hyacinth Alia | Nigeria | Governor of Benue State (2023–present) | [14] |
| Louis Ambane | Papua New Guinea | Governor of Chimbu (1997–1998) Member of Parliament (1997–1998; 1999–2003) |
[15] |
| Jean-Bertrand Aristide | Haiti | President of Haiti (1991) | |
| Xabier Arzalluz* | Spain | Member of the Congress of Deputies (1977–1980) | |
| Barthélemy Boganda* | France Central African Republic |
Member of the National Assembly of France (1946–1958) Premier of the Central African Republic (1958–1960) |
|
| Martial Boni Boni | Ivory Coast | Member of the Independent Electoral Commission (2014–2019) | [3] |
| Denis Bradley | United Kingdom | Vice Chairman of the Northern Ireland Policing Board (2001–2006) | [16] |
| David Cairns | United Kingdom | Member of Parliament (2001–2011) Minister of State for Scotland (2005–2008) |
|
| Ernesto Cardenal | Nicaragua | Minister of Culture (1979–1987) | |
| Fernando Cardenal | Nicaragua | Minister of Education (1984–1990) | |
| Robert John Cornell | United States | Member of the House of Representatives (1975–1979) | |
| France Cukjati | Slovenia | State Secretary for Primary Healthcare (2000) Member of the National Assembly (2000–2011) Speaker of the National Assembly (2004–2008) Deputy Speaker of the National Assembly (2008–2011) |
|
| Enrico Dandria | Malta | Member of the National Assembly (1919) | [17] |
| Robert Drinan | United States | Member of the House of Representatives (1971–1981) | |
| Jerome D'Souza | India | Member of the Constituent Assembly (1946–1950) | |
| Simon Dumarinu | Papua New Guinea | Member of Parliament (2021–2024) | [18] |
| Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann | Nicaragua Libya |
Minister of Foreign Affairs of Nicaragua (1979–1990) Ambassador of Libya to the United Nations (2011) |
|
| Eligius Fromentin | United States | Secretary of the Louisiana State Senate (1812–1813) Member of the Senate (1813–1819) Judge of the New Orleans Criminal Court (1821) Territorial Judge (1821–1822) |
|
| José Manuel Gallegos | United States | Delegate to the House of Representatives (1853–1856; 1871–1873) | |
| John Garia | Papua New Guinea | Governor of Chimbu (2007–2012) Member of Parliament (2007–2012) |
|
| Augustine Geve | Solomon Islands | Member of Parliament (2001–2002) Minister of Youth, Women and Sports (2001–2002) |
|
| Raymond Gravel | Canada | Member of Parliament (2006–2008) | [19] |
| Ivan Grubišić | Croatia | Member of Parliament (2011–2015) | |
| Daniel Herman* | Czech Republic | Member of Chamber of Deputies (2013–2017) Minister of Culture (1920–1933) |
|
| Andrej Hlinka | Czechoslovakia | Member of the National Assembly (1920–1938) | |
| Andrew Hogan | Canada | Member of Parliament (1974–1980) | [19] |
| Theodor Innitzer | Austria | Minister of Social Affairs (1929–1930) | |
| Filomeno Jacob | Timor-Leste (UNTAET) | Minister for Social Affairs (2000–2001) | [20] |
| Ludwig Kaas | Germany | Member of the Weimar National Assembly (1919–1920) Member of the Reichstag (1920–1933) |
|
| Félix Kir | France | Mayor of Dijon (1945–1968) Member of the National Assembly (1945–1967) |
[21] |
| Hugo Kołłątaj | Poland | Vice-Chancellor of the Crown (1791–1792) | |
| Philippe Fanoko Kpodzro | Togo | President of the High Council of the Republic (1991) President of the National Assembly (1991–1994) |
[22] |
| Robert Lak | Papua New Guinea | Governor of Western Highlands (1997–2002) Member of Parliament (1997–2002) |
|
| Segundo Llorente | United States | Member of the Alaska House of Representatives (1961–1963) | |
| Simon Lokodo | Uganda | Member of Parliament (2006–2021) Minister of State for Industry and Technology (2009–2011) Minister of State for Ethics and Integrity (2011–2021) Member of the Uganda Human Rights Commission (2021–2022) |
[23] |
| Emerson Luego | Philippines | Mayor of Mabini, Davao de Oro (2022–present) | [24] |
| Fernando Lugo* | Paraguay | President of Paraguay (2008–2012) Member of the Senate (2013–2023) |
|
| Apollinaire Malu Malu | DR Congo | President of the Independent National Electoral Commission (2013–2015) | [3] |
| Gabriel Manek | East Indonesia | Member of the Provisional Representative Body (1946–1950) | |
| Michael McKee | Canada | Member of the Legislative Assembly of New Brunswick (1974–1992) Provincial Minister of Labour and Multiculturalism (1987–1991) Judge of the Provincial Court of New Brunswick (1992–2015) |
[25] |
| John McLaughlin | United States | Speechwriter and advisor to President Richard Nixon (1971–1974) | [26][27] |
| Fernando Arturo de Meriño | Dominican Republic | President of the Chamber of Deputies (1878–1883) President of the Dominican Republic (1880–1882) |
|
| Smangaliso Mkhatshwa | South Africa | Member of Parliament (1994–1999) Deputy Minister of Education (1996–1999) Mayor of Tshwane (2000–2006) |
[28][29] |
| John Momis | Papua and New Guinea Papua New Guinea |
Member of the House of Assembly (1972–1975) Member of Parliament (1977–2005) Deputy Prime Minister (1985–1988) Governor of Bougainville (1999–2005) President of Bougainville (2010–2020) |
|
| Laurent Monsengwo Pasinya | Zaire | President of the Sovereign National Conference (1991) President of the High Council of the Republic (1992–1994) Speaker of the Transitional Parliament (1994–1995) |
[30] |
| Romolo Murri | Italy | Member of the Chamber of Deputies (1909–1913) | [31] |
| Gioan Baotixita Nguyễn Văn Riễn | Vietnam | Member of the National Assembly (2016–2021) | [32] |
| Charles J. O'Byrne | United States | Secretary to the Governor of New York (2008) | [33] |
| Robert Ogle | Canada | Member of Parliament (1979–1984) | [19] |
| Charles Onen | Uganda | Member of Parliament (2021–present) | [34] |
| Joseph Owusu-Agyeman | Ghana | Justice of the High Court (2020–present) | [3] |
| Ignazio Panzavecchia | Malta | Member of the Council of Government (1891–1892) Member of the National Assembly (1919) Member of the Senate (1921–1925) |
[35] |
| Gabriel Richard | United States | Delegate to the House of Representatives (1823–1825) | |
| Ignaz Seipel | Austria | Minister of Public Works and Social Welfare (1918) Chancellor of Austria (1922–1924; 1926–1929) Minister of the Interior (1923–1924; 1926–1929) Minister of Foreign Affairs (1926–1929; 1930) |
|
| Stanisław Staszic | Duchy of Warsaw Poland |
Minister of State of the Duchy of Warsaw (1809–1810) State Councillor of the Duchy of Warsaw (1810–1815) Ministry of Industry of Poland (1816–1824) Minister of State of Poland (1824–1826) |
|
| Josip Juraj Strossmayer | Austria Austria-Hungary |
Member of the Imperial Council (1860) Grand Prefect of Virovitica County (1861–1862) Member of the Croatian Parliament (1861–1873) |
|
| Luigi Sturzo | Italy | Vice-Mayor of Caltagirone (1905–1920) Member of the Senate (1952–1959) |
|
| Romy Tiongco | Philippines | Mayor of Damulog (2007–2016) | |
| Jozef Tiso | Czechoslovakia Slovakia |
Minister of Health of Czechoslovakia (1927–1929) Minister of the Interior of Slovakia Prime Minister of Slovakia (1938–1939) President of the Slovak Republic (1939–1945) |
|
| Jean-Marie Tjibaou* | New Caledonia | Mayor of Hienghène (1977–1989) Vice-president of the Government Council (1982–1984) |
|
| Beda Weber | Germany | Member of the Frankfurt National Assembly (1848–1849) | |
| Fulbert Youlou* | French Congo Congo |
Mayor of Brazzaville (1956) Prime Minister of the Republic of the Congo (1958–1959) Presidents of the Republic of the Congo (1960–1963) |
- laicized before taking office
See also
- List of Christian clergy in politics
- Separation of church and state
References
- Back to citation Kevin Schmiesing. "John A. Ryan, Virgil Michel, and the problem of clerical politics". VLex.com.
- Back to citation occurrence 2.0 Back to citation occurrence 2.1 Code of Canon Law. 1983. Can. 285.
- Back to citation occurrence 3.0 Back to citation occurrence 3.1 Back to citation occurrence 3.2 Back to citation occurrence 3.3 Back to citation occurrence 3.4 Back to citation occurrence 3.5 Sarr, Lucie (2020-09-25). "Is it right for priests to hold political or civic office?". La Croix International. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation occurrence 4.0 Back to citation occurrence 4.1 Back to citation occurrence 4.2 Theodorou, Angelina E. (2014-07-22). "In 30 countries, heads of state must belong to a certain religion". Pew Research Center. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation "Paraguay 1992 (rev. 2011) Constitution". Constitute. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation "Myanmar 2008 Constitution". Constitute. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation Gomez Aban, M. Fernanda. "Mexico 1917 (rev. 2015) Constitution". Constitute. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation McDaniel v. Paty, 435 U.S. 618 (U.S. 1978).
- Back to citation "Priest MP leaves politics after pressure from Vatican". CBC. 3 September 2008.
- Back to citation Percival, Jenny (2008-09-16). "Profile: David Cairns". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2023-10-18.
- Back to citation Davis, Francis (23 April 2009). "The cardinal must not become a peer". The Guardian.
- Back to citation "Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O'Connor turns down peerage following Catholic row". 6 December 2009.
- Back to citation Martin, Douglas (12 May 2009). "Robert J. Cornell, Priest Who Served as Congressman, Is Dead at 89". obituary. The New York Times.
- Back to citation occurrence 14.0 Back to citation occurrence 14.1 Burton, Douglas (2023-07-02). "Suspended priest takes charge of Nigeria's strife-torn Benue State". Catholic News Agency. Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation Fong, Lawrence (2024-09-02). "The Catholic Church and Politics: A PNG perspective". Post Courier. Retrieved 2024-11-30.
- Back to citation "Denis Bradley". MacGill Summer School. 2019-06-27. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation Muscat, Jake (2023-06-25). "Mgr Enrico Dandria: Priest, politician & patriot". The Malta Independent. Retrieved 2024-11-18.
- Back to citation "3 influential men pass on". The National. 2024-11-29. Retrieved 2024-11-30.
- Back to citation occurrence 19.0 Back to citation occurrence 19.1 Back to citation occurrence 19.2 "The Register Archive: Fr. Andy Hogan is Parliament's first priest-MP". The Catholic Register. 2018-07-10. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
- Back to citation "UNTAET, East Timor shape new cabinet and legislative body". Tais Timor. 1 (12). 6 August 2000. Retrieved 19 December 2021.
- Back to citation Januel, Pierre (2025-07-20). "The extraordinary life and career of French MP Félix Kir". Mediapart. Retrieved 2026-03-25.
- Back to citation Atemanke, Jude (2024-01-09). "Catholic Archbishop Known for Freedom, Democracy Advocacy in Togo Dies at 93". ACI Africa. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation "Uganda ex-minister Simon Lokodo dies in Geneva". The EastAfrican. 2022-01-29. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation Bulosan, Chrislen (2022-05-12). "Priest wins mayoral race in Davao De Oro". ABS-CBN News. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation "Order of Moncton - Judge Michael McKee". Moncton. 2019-08-31. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
- Back to citation "RIP John McLaughlin: 'Nixon's priest,' speechwriter, talk show host". Aleteia. 2016-08-16. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
- Back to citation "Jesuit Was Ordered to Quit as Ford Aide". The New York Times. 1974-10-13. Retrieved 2024-11-21.
- Back to citation "Father Smangaliso Mkhatshwa". The Presidency. Retrieved 2024-11-30.
- Back to citation "Father Mkhathswa". South African Local Government Association. Retrieved 2024-11-30.
- Back to citation "Congolese cardinal, peace activist, dies at 81". Crux. 2021-07-12. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation Guasco, Maurilio (2012). "MURRI, Romolo". Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani. 77.
- Back to citation Ngô, Quốc Đông (2021-05-15). "Vị linh mục luôn hướng đến người nghèo" [The priest always turns to the poor]. Nhân Dân (in Vietnamese). Retrieved 2024-11-17.
- Back to citation Confessore, Nicholas; Hakim, Danny (2008-10-24). "Paterson Aide Quits in Furor Over His Taxes". The New York Times.
- Back to citation "Priest who defied his Bishop to become an MP". NTV Uganda. 2021-01-31. Retrieved 2024-11-20.
- Back to citation Schiavone, Michael (2023-11-21). "Biography: Ignazio Panzavecchia". Times of Malta. Retrieved 2024-11-17.